DesignatedEducatedExperiencedConnected

Insight: REIBC blog
Advancing the conversation on land and real estate issues in BC.

Insight: REIBC blog > Unproven Energy Needs Can’t Justify Site C

Unproven Energy Needs Can’t Justify Site C

posted on 10:35 AM, June 30, 2017
Peace-Valley_flickr_DeSmog-Canada_Emma-Gilchrist_2014_14524016250_c6d2fc64b9_o.jpg
Eighty-three kilometres of the Peace Valley will be flooded once Site C is built. credit: Emma Gilchrist, DeSmog Canada (flickrCC)

Site C will flood 83 kilometres of the Peace River valley. This will destroy almost 16,000 acres of farmland in the traditional territory of the Treaty 8 First Nations. It will displace residents, some of whose families have been homesteading there for generations. And it will cause the loss of rare plants, terrestrial wildlife, fish habitat, and historical resources. With these impacts, can the project be justified?

West Coast Environmental Law’s staff council Anna Johnston doesn’t think it can, and she points to the conclusions of the Joint Review Panel for support. “The Panel held that the cumulative effects of these impacts, both in combination with each other and when considered in the context of the multiple agricultural, silvicultural and industrial developments in the area, would not just diminish biodiversity in the Peace Region, but result in a loss to world biodiversity and heritage,” writes Johnston.

The Panel itself writes in its report: “Justification [for Site C] must rest on an unambiguous need for the power…” Summarized by Johnston, the Panel’s conclusion was that “BC Hydro failed to prove that Site C is the answer to BC’s energy needs.”

input-spring-2017.jpg
Download Spring 2017

Read more about the significant costs of Site C and the challenges of forecasting long-term energy needs in “Site C Dam: The Best Option for New Energy BC Doesn’t Need,” in the Spring 2017 issue of Input, page 28. Download Spring 2017

More information about the 2014 Report of the Joint Review Panel

Join the conversation on Facebook

Recent Articles

Future Food Security Requires Data Now posted on 10:37 AM, September 22, 2017 in Insight: REIBC blog

Data Enables Transit-Oriented Development posted on 10:32 AM, September 1, 2017 in Insight: REIBC blog

Planning Neighbourhoods posted on 10:40 AM, August 11, 2017 in Insight: REIBC blog

Resident Concern for Site C posted on 11:08 AM, July 21, 2017 in Insight: REIBC blog

Unproven Energy Needs Can’t Justify Site C posted on 10:35 AM, June 30, 2017 in Insight: REIBC blog

Let’s Talk About Community Interests posted on 10:23 AM, June 9, 2017 in Insight: REIBC blog

Exploring the Costs of Site C posted on 10:50 AM, May 19, 2017 in Insight: REIBC blog

About BC Hydro’s Site C Clean Energy Project posted on 10:03 AM, April 28, 2017 in Insight: REIBC blog

District of Ucluelet posted on 8:01 AM, March 3, 2017 in Insight: REIBC blog

Earthquake and Emergency Preparedness in BC posted on 11:46 AM, February 17, 2017 in Insight: REIBC blog